Don’t find it funny? Please continue reading.
The phrase “women hold up half the sky” just got popular lately with the Women’s March. It’s poetic, touching and empowering. Does it sound fresh and creative to you? As a Chinese, it’s so familiar that it gave me an illusion of traveling in time and space.
The phrase was a communist propaganda came out during the Great Leap Forward movement in China in the late 50’s. Some think it’s from Chairman Mao but it’s not officially documented. When human labor was scarce, the government started the women’s liberation movement, encouraged women to join the workforce. It initiated women to get out of the house to work in the fields and factories, get equal payment with men. No matter what’s the initial intention of this movement, more and more women joined the social activities, it’s liberating and progressive at the time.
“Women hold up half the sky”–Women’s images are strong, powerful and hardworking in the posters during the time.
It all seemed beautiful and empowering, right? But the other part of the story is probably less told. When women’s rights were super emphasized in the workforce, women’s contribution at home was devalued almost completely. When women were given the rights to work, they were taken away the rights to take care of their family or even to give birth. The society was designed that shortly after having children, people had to go back to work and gave the babies to raise by all kinds of child care facilities.
When my mother had me, she had to work in a factory 7 to 5, leaving me with the factory held childcare. Most of the Chinese babies in the cities weren’t breastfed. The lucky ones were cared by grandparents before going to kindergarten at age of 3.
As we all know, having babies and raising children takes the majority of a women’s time. If you want women to work more, it should be eliminated as much as possible. There came the late marriage and late childbearing policy and one child policy in the 70’s.
“Control birth rate for the revolution.”
“late marriage and late childbirth, control birth rate, free the women labor.”
The employment rates of Chinese women are still one of the highest in the world. “It means women do hold up half the sky!” We’re proud about our women’s equal rights. While it’s true that women in China have gained a lot of freedom of education and work, there are other problems. Stay at home moms have no social support and benefit, often are discriminated against; Marriage laws are economically unfavorable to women who spend time with children instead of work; Divorce rate has been rising, family values are disappearing; Generations of children are separated from their parents at young ages. To go and hold up half the sky, how many women are doing it by choice? And at what cost?
I believe that the American people who marched and held the sign have all the good intentions. I think it’s necessary to understand the origin of the slogan, its good and bad effects in the history, and the ideology behind it.
The links that say (on my computer) “Inline image” are linking to a gmail inbox (so I can’t see any images you might be trying to link to.
Thanks for pointing it out! I reposted those images, please let me know if you still have trouble seeing them.
I can see them now! Thank you for reposting!
All so beautifully put. Thanks for sharing!
Thank you for explaining the historical background of women holds half sky! I was a little girl at the tail end of culture revolution. I suffer from a failed marriage. I blame myself for not having the traditional family value and didn’t appreciate my partner, didn’t know women are the glue to hold family together. Now it all explains. (J/k)
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi! I’m from Brazil and I’m studying women in China, but I had so much trouble searching for womens social and political rights among the years and your text explaned so much to me! I’m glad I found you (and your comics too haha), and If I may ask, do you have any sources online that I could read more about women situation since the 50’s?
I’m sorry if I’m asking too much, but I hope you could help me somehow.
Congratulations to your work, and all the best to your family!
Before I went to secondary school, my mum was a stay-at-home mum cos my dad wanted her to care for my brother and I and didnt want her to work. As a little child, I though my dad was a male chauvinist. However as I grew older, I realised the merits of having a stay-at-home mum and this is especially so when I later have children of own. It is a taunting task to juggle work and family. Someone has to sacrifice to spend more time with the children, either the mother or the father. If not why bother to have children when the parents cannot afford to spend time with them? It is more tiring to care for children than to have a full time job. Do not discriminate against women who stay at home for their families.
Do you actually live in China?
No. I’m living in Seattle now.
if mother is whole sky to a kid so, I mean, is this woman mutated into a new species that having ability of the Parthenogenesis?